In Fifth Business, Amasa Dempster's eyes are vividly described as scarecrow-like, signaling displacement and haunted experience. This image underlines themes of perception, suffering, and human complexity, while highlighting how other characters react to his unsettling presence and fate.

Multiple Choice

Which character is described as having "eyes like a scarecrow"?

The character described as having "eyes like a scarecrow" is Amasa Dempster. This description captures Amasa's unsettling presence and reflects his role as a symbol of dislocation and neglect within the novel. His eyes convey a sense of otherness and his haunted life experiences, particularly his tragic fate and the impact it has on those around him. This vivid imagery also helps to evoke a visual parallel to his spiritual and emotional state, reinforcing themes of suffering, perception, and the complexities of human nature in the story. While Dunstan Ramsay, Gyges, and Little Madonna are significant characters in "Fifth Business," their descriptions and contexts do not match the unsettling imagery associated with a scarecrow, which emphasizes Amasa's unique and haunting character traits.

A Scarecrow’s Gaze: Reading Amasa Dempster in Fifth Business

Robertson Davies’s Fifth Business is a novel that wears its ideas lightly on the surface while hiding a parade of heavy, moving parts just beneath. It’s a book that asks big questions about memory, guilt, and how a small event can bend a life into a shape it wouldn’t have chosen on its own. When you meet the characters, you don’t just see them—you almost feel them breathing in the margins of the page. And sometimes a single line of description can feel like a doorway. In this case, the line is about eyes: “eyes like a scarecrow.” The character with that unnerving gaze is Amasa Dempster, not the witty or ostensibly central figure, but a presence who casts a disquieting shadow across the novel’s field.

Let me explain why that image sticks. A scarecrow, after all, is designed to be watched from a distance. It stands still, it watches, it bears the weather, and it signals a boundary between the living world and the field’s untamed corners. Amasa Dempster is cast in a similar role, but Davies isn’t using him as a simple symbol of rustic neglect. He’s more of a flare—a signpost that signals how the world can feel off-kilter, even when nothing overtly dramatic is happening in the foreground. Amasa’s eyes, described as “like a scarecrow,” invite us to see beyond the outward polish of a small Ontario town and into the undercurrents of perception and neglect that Davies wants to explore.

Who is Amasa Dempster, and why does his gaze matter? He’s not the hero with a grand arc, not the narrator who turns the pages with a magnetic charm. Instead, Amasa is a character whose very presence unsettles others, a living mirror that reflects the town’s unease, its repressed memories, and its unspoken judgments. The scarecrow image works on multiple levels. It’s a visual cue that an observer might mistake for harmless silliness or a harmless oddity, until you notice that the eyes are watching a landscape they don’t quite belong to—one that holds pain, sometimes passively, sometimes with a half-smiled cruelty.

This is the kind of literary device Davies loves. He doesn’t hit you over the head with melodrama. He tends to tuck his insights into sharp, almost offhand descriptions. The line about Dempster’s eyes is a microcosm of Davies’s broader technique: prosaic surface, unsettling undertone. It makes the reader pause, reframe, and then reconsider what the character’s role might be in the grand scheme of the story. We’re not just looking at a person; we’re noticing how a person’s gaze can map a history of dislocation, neglect, and a life lived on the edge of a community’s moral field.

To understand why Amasa fits this particular image, it’s helpful to consider the novel’s larger themes. Fifth Business is a meditation on how small acts ripple outward, shaping identities in ways that are not always admirable, sometimes even brutal. The term “fifth business” itself comes from a notion in a stage performance: the people who don’t speak the lines, who stand off to the side, yet whose presence is essential to the entire play. Amasa, in his lowered, almost spectral presence, embodies the shadow side of that concept. He’s not up on stage delivering dialogue with flair; he’s the kind of character who lingers in the wings, whose life story bleeds into the central plot through consequences rather than overt heroics. In that sense, his eyes—watchful, wary, and a touch haunted—are the perfect visual shorthand for the theme Davies is probing: how do we perceive those who fall outside the social center, and how do those perceptions shape their fate?

Let’s wander a bit through the other characters who populate the same pages. Dunstan Ramsay—the protagonist and lifelong observer of the human condition—moves with the confidence of someone who thinks he’s decoding the pattern of a life. Gyges, a name that echoes myth and wrongdoing, carries a different kind of weight, a reminder that perception can be a weapon, and memory—a far more complex thing—can be a trap. Little Madonna, as a figure of icon and maternal tenderness and also of mythic construction, functions as a different kind of focal point around which others orbit. Yet none of these characters inhabit the same spectral space as Amasa. They are legible within the conventional drama of a narrative, while Amasa presses at the edge, reminding us that the story’s moral weather isn’t a single, clear forecast. It’s nuanced, sometimes uncomfortable, and often quieter than any dramatic confrontation.

That quietness is not a flaw; it’s Davies’s method for coaxing us into a more reflective mode. The scarecrow gaze is an invitation to notice what’s not being said as much as what is. It’s the presence of a life that has endured, a life that has borne witness to suffering and, perhaps, the consequences of a society that prefers to look away. The image suggests a kind of weather-beaten endurance, an ability to stand through storms while the world passes by, not always seeing what lies beneath the façade of rural steadiness. In the way Davies deploys this descriptor, the reader learns to read not just faces but atmospheres—what a look can reveal about a person’s interior life, and how that interior life spills into the lives of others in unpredictable ways.

In Fifth Business, perception is a powerful currency. The scarecrow-eyed Amasa embodies the tension between appearance and truth. The town may present a polished surface—friendly, conservative, orderly—but the eyes that peer from the margins tell a different tale. They’re not merely “unsettling”; they’re access points to a history of neglect, not just for Amasa but for the social fabric that has neglected him as well. Davies is playing with the idea that to see someone clearly is not just to judge them, but to recognize the weight of unseen experiences—the injuries carried in memory, the unspoken stories that accumulate until they become almost tangible.

If you’re listening to or reading Fifth Business with a close ear, you’ll notice a pattern: Davies uses sensory details to anchor moral questions. A phrase like “eyes like a scarecrow” does more than describe a look; it creates a mood, a tether to the past, and a cue for readers to examine their own responses to figures who don’t fit neatly into the narrative’s center. It’s easy to dismiss a scarecrow as a simple rural prop, a reminder of harvests and days past. Davies, though, turns that object into a living metaphor: a witness, a sentinel, a haunting reminder that not everyone moves through life with equal visibility or equal protection under the community’s gaze.

The emotional texture of this moment also invites a gentle, almost unspoken empathy. Amasa’s eyes—haunting, watchful—signal a life of dislocation, yes, but also resilience and the burden of bearing witness. The reader isn’t simply asked to feel pity or fear; the text nudges us to consider the moral geometry of a community that can be indifferent to the harm it inflicts, or the harm it tolerates until it becomes personal. Davies’s artistry lies in this delicate balance: he gives us a character who unsettles without sensationalizing, who complicates the simple binaries of good and bad, and who remains memorable long after the page is turned.

The image also dovetails with the novel’s broader exploration of perception versus reality. In Davies’s world, what a person looks like, how they’re described, and how others choose to remember them all influence the tapestry of meaning that readers assemble. Amasa’s scarecrow gaze becomes a touchstone for this idea. It pushes us to consider how much of a life is legible to the world, and how much is only legible to a few who really look—the kind of look that isn’t flattered by social niceties, the look that sees the lacerations beneath the surface and refuses to pretend otherwise.

For readers who enjoy tracking the strands of symbolism, Amasa offers a compact, potent thread. The scarecrow is an emblem of exposure without agency, of a life pinned in place by circumstance, memory, and the judgments of others. Davies doesn’t tell us to pity him in a melodramatic way; rather, he invites a sober awareness: we all carry sides of ourselves that the world might not want to acknowledge, and the way we gaze at others can reveal as much about us as about them. In the end, the scarecrow-eyed figure becomes a mirror for the reader, a prompt to examine how much of our own vision is shaped by what we prefer to see.

If you’re teaching or studying Fifth Business, or simply letting Davies’s prose wash over you on a quiet afternoon, here are a few takeaways to hold onto:

  • Visual language matters. Even a single image—eyes like a scarecrow—can carry a mountain of meaning. It’s not just about how a character looks; it’s about how that look signals a broader ethical and emotional landscape.

  • Peripheral figures often illuminate central questions. Amasa is not the loudest voice, but his presence sharpens the novel’s inquiry into memory, neglect, and what it means to belong or to be noticed.

  • Perception is recursive. How the townspeople see Amasa shapes how Amasa exists in the story, which in turn reshapes how other characters respond to him. The loop is a reminder that reality in Davies’s world is co-authored by readers and characters alike.

So, when you revisit the pages and you come across that exact line—eyes like a scarecrow—take a moment to linger there. Let the image float in your mind and ask yourself: what does that gaze reveal, and what does it conceal? It’s a small, precise doorway into a larger conversation about memory, community, and the quiet, stubborn ways people carry their own weather inside them.

In the end, Davies reminds us that literature isn’t just about plot twists or grand declarations. It’s about careful attention—the kind that notices a look and asks why it matters. Amasa Dempster’s eyes, so memorably described, become a beacon for that kind of attention. They anchor a moment that might otherwise drift past, and they invite us to consider how much of a life is seen, and how much remains just beyond the frame of the everyday.

And yes, the scarecrow continues to watch—not in judgment, but in unfinished curiosity. A reminder that the world is full of people who carry stories that never quite fit the town’s tidy expectations. If you lean into that line and let it pull you along, you’ll find Fifth Business isn’t just a story about a man named Ramsay or a town in a particular time and place. It’s a meditation on viewing, on listening, and on the enduring truth that every gaze has a history. For readers who relish that kind of depth, Davies’s work is a lifelong invitation to look a little closer—and to discover that the most haunting images are often the quietest ones.